Sunday, February 16, 2014

Blog 9- Support and Challenges in Nonfiction and fiction texts


Nonfiction text
Stomp Out Bullying
Text Structure (compare contrast, problem/solution, sequence, etc…)
Support- The text is outlined in a problem/solution format. If students know what the structure is, it will help them comprehend the text more.
Vocabulary
Challenge-When using nonfiction text at the 7th grade level, you can expect for there to be higher level vocabulary as well. Students who have not had previous exposure to it can struggle with meaning in the text.
Text Features (pictures, captions, headings, subtitles, side bars, etc…)
Challenge- Students who do not understand the purpose behind text features and can get confused as to what they are for.
Support- Visual aids help paint a visual image. Titles and headings can provide a main idea for the students, so they understand what is happening. Bolded words can provide definitions and highlight key vocabulary content.
Authors Purpose
Challenge- This text gave facts about bullying and what you should do if you see it happening. This can be confusing to students if they are not familiar with persuasive techniques. Some students may not understand that the author really wanted them to stand up to bullies and not just know the facts.
Point of View
Support-This was easy as it was a 3rd person. The author was informing about bullying. One person talking.
Content
Support- No matter where you are from, you have seen or heard of bullying in one form or another. This content can cross cultural barriers.


Fiction Text
The Lottery- Shirley Jackson
Plot
Challenge- This story can be very hard to follow because nothing is just stated. Students need to be able to infer a great amount in this story. I think that the biggest part that they will struggle understanding is that Tessie dies at the end. Also, that the lottery is bad.
Characters
Challenge - There were many characters in this story and it could be hard to remember who the main character was. Support- Even though there were a lot of different characters, all of the characters were relatable.
Vocabulary
Challenge- This higher level text provided vocabulary that was hard for even English speaking students. No matter who was reading this, they would more than likely struggle with the vocabulary. Students can possibly get caught up with the notion that the lottery is something good because the way it is used today (win millions).
Point of View
Support- 3rd person. You could follow who was talking and when it transferred to another person. You knew all thoughts.
Setting
Support- Some of our ELL students came from villages in Africa, so they were able to understand the unique dynamics that go on inside of one. Setting stayed the same through the entire story.
Figurative Language
Challenge- Many examples of figurative language are used in this text. Students need to have background knowledge in order to understand these.

No comments:

Post a Comment